How to Respond to Conflicting Peer Reviewer Comments
Reading time - 7 minutes
Introduction
Conflicting reviewer comments are common and can confuse even experienced authors. Learning how to navigate contradictions is a key academic skill.
Why Reviewer Conflicts Occur
Reasons include:
- Different theoretical perspectives
- Methodological preferences
- Disciplinary norms
How Editors Expect Authors to Respond
Editors want:
- Clear explanations
- Balanced responses
- Evidence‑based decisions
Step‑by‑Step Response Strategy
- Identify conflicts
- Explain chosen approach
- Justify with evidence
- Communicate clearly to editor
Conclusion
Conflicting reviews are not a barrier to acceptance when handled thoughtfully. Clear, respectful responses help editors make informed decisions.